Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Sean O'Malley Says Ciryl Gane's Uncalled Eye Poke Cost Josh Hokit a Draw at UFC 334

Gane kept the heavyweight belt on a 48-47 card while Hokit said he saw triple for four rounds and spent the night in a hospital until 5 a.m.

Sean O'Malley
Photo: Sean O'Malley: U.S. Department of the Interior, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Josh Hokit spent Saturday night in a hospital until 5 a.m. getting his eye looked at. The man who poked it walked out of UFC 334 still the heavyweight champion of the world. If that sentence doesn’t bother you, I’d like to know what sport you think you’re watching.

Here’s what happened, per Bloody Elbow. In the first round of a five-round title fight, Ciryl Gane stuck his fingers in Hokit’s eye. Hokit grabbed at it right away. The broadcast team noticed and called it out on air. The referee did not, and no point came off the board. Gane went on to win a unanimous decision, handing The Incredible Hok his first career loss, and the fight was close enough that Gane took it by a single round, 48-47.

Do the math with me for a second. One point off in Round 1 and that’s a draw. Hokit doesn’t lose his zero. And that’s the conservative version of the damage, because Hokit said afterward he was seeing triple for the rest of the fight. Picture fighting a 36-year-old heavyweight champion for four more rounds like you wandered into a 3D movie without the glasses. That’s what he did, and he still nearly got there.

O’Malley wants a man in the truck

Sean O’Malley watched the replay and lost his patience on his YouTube channel.

“They just replayed the first round, Ciryl Gane clearly poked him in the eye,” O’Malley said. “The eye poke made a difference. If they took a point away from Ciryl Gane, it would’ve been a draw.”

Then he got to the part I actually care about. “Why isn’t there somebody in a truck, why is there not somebody that everyone trusts, somebody that can call these fouls from a truck,” he asked, later adding, “It clearly happened, the ref didn’t see it, that’s not Josh Hokit’s fault the ref didn’t see it.”

Sportskeeda’s headline on the same rant quoted him with two words that should be printed on a banner and hung in every commission office in America: “Minus two points.”

Suga is right, and the fix he’s describing is boring, cheap and obvious. Put an official at the production truck with the same replay angles the broadcast already has, give him a line to the referee’s ear, and let him flag a foul the ref missed. The footage existed in real time. The commentators saw it in real time. The only person in the building who acted like it didn’t happen was the one person with the power to do something about it. O’Malley summed up the absurdity better than I can: “just because the ref didn’t see it, it doesn’t count?”

Gane has a history here

If this were a one-off, I’d grumble and move on. It isn’t. Tom Aspinall is still out of action with eye injuries from his fight with Gane at UFC 321. That fight is how we got here in the first place, with Aspinall eventually vacating and Gane getting promoted to undisputed champion, a move Bloody Elbow notes fans weren’t thrilled about given who caused the injury. Now the guy’s first big title fight with the full belt ends with his opponent in a hospital bed getting tests on his eye. Two straight headline fights, two straight conversations about where Gane’s fingers were.

O’Malley said the UFC needs to take action given how many incidents Gane has piled up, and that refs need to start calling it. I’ll go a step past him. Make an eye poke an automatic point deduction. No warning, no “take your time,” no gentle reminder to close the hand.

The obvious pushback is that pokes are usually accidental. Fine. Low blows are usually accidental too, and we still expect fighters to aim somewhere else. Per Bloody Elbow, fighters already get warned about this exact foul in their backstage briefings with officials before every card. So the warning has been delivered. Everybody in that cage knows the rule. What’s missing is any reason to obey it. When an open hand costs you nothing, there’s no incentive to keep your fingers out of a man’s face, and the fighters who are sloppy about it get rewarded for being sloppy. That’s how a 48-47 decision ends up hinging on a foul nobody penalized.

I’m a sucker for a great champion. I want Gane’s reign to be about the movement, the kicks and the cardio that make him one of the most fun heavyweights to watch. Instead his title run keeps turning into a medical report. That’s on him for his hands, and on the officials for letting it slide twice on the biggest nights of the year.

Hokit lost his undefeated record on a night he couldn’t see straight, and the commission had every replay it needed to make it a draw. The next time Gane fights for that belt, somebody had better be sitting in the truck.

Keep reading