Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
News

Kayla Harrison Choked Out Amanda Nunes and Still Couldn't Grab the No. 1 Spot

Harrison earned one first-place vote and jumped past Zhang Weili in MMA Fighting's pound-for-pound rankings, but Valentina Shevchenko held the top spot despite nearly a year on the shelf.

Kayla Harrison
Photo: Kayla Harrison: The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Kayla Harrison submitted Amanda Nunes, and the rankings moved. They didn’t move all the way. In MMA Fighting’s updated women’s pound-for-pound list, released Tuesday after UFC 334, Harrison climbed from No. 3 to No. 2, passing Zhang Weili. She also picked up one No. 1 vote from the five-person panel. Valentina Shevchenko kept the top spot.

The win came Saturday at Madison Square Garden, where Harrison finished Nunes with a rear-naked choke in Round 4. Nunes, a former two-division champion with a long list of title defenses, was returning from a three-year layoff. MMA Fighting’s writeup pointed to three problems for her that night: the rust, Harrison’s grappling, and a game plan the outlet called bewildering. Harrison was also coming back from something. This was her first fight since major neck surgery.

ESPN’s rankings coverage led with the same idea. Its headlines said Harrison returned to lead an overhaul of the women’s divisional rankings, and that Harrison and Nunes had reclaimed leading roles in the women’s pound-for-pound top 10. MMA Fighting’s panel was harder on Nunes and slotted her back in at No. 15.

Why Shevchenko is still on top

The panel is made up of Alexander K. Lee, Guilherme Cruz, Mike Heck, Damon Martin and Jed Meshew, and four of the five stayed with Shevchenko. Their reasoning was about résumé. Harrison’s body of work is nowhere near as deep as Shevchenko’s or Zhang’s, and the outlet described her weight class as one of the most maligned divisions in MMA. Shevchenko’s case has its own weak spot. She has been out for almost a year and had to give up her flyweight title because of inactivity. Zhang, per MMA Fighting, is stuck in matchmaking limbo. Lee put the question to his followers on X shortly after the list went up: “Kayla No. 1 P4P? Yay? Nay?”

The rest of the women’s list had plenty going on. Jasmine Jasudavicius rose seven spots after upsetting Erin Blanchfield, who came in at No. 9. Jena Bishop debuted on the list after beating Liz Carmouche to become the inaugural PFL flyweight champion. That loss knocked Carmouche out of the rankings, and Sabrinna de Sousa fell out too. Natalia Silva beat Wang Cong, and Tatiana Suarez beat Virna Jandiroba. None of the ranked women currently have a bout scheduled.

MMA Fighting also raised the possibility that Harrison walks away. The outlet framed it as speculation, a guess based on how many boxes she has already checked, starting with two Olympic gold medals in judo before she ever fought in a cage. Nothing in the reporting says she has decided.

My take: four voters holding firm on Shevchenko is defensible, and I’d probably have voted the same way. Harrison went into Madison Square Garden with a surgically repaired neck and beat the most accomplished woman the sport has produced, which is a real win. But it’s one win, and one fight shouldn’t hand anybody the top spot. The panel’s own rules will settle Shevchenko’s case either way, because any fighter who goes 18 months without competing in a weight class is removed. That clock is already running.

Keep reading