Josh Hokit lost a fight last weekend, and now he wants to abolish the scorecard. That’s the short version. The longer version is funnier.
At UFC 334 at Madison Square Garden, Hokit dropped a unanimous decision to Ciryl Gane in a heavyweight title fight that BJPenn.com called one of the most exciting bouts of 2026. It was the first loss of his MMA career. He seemed to take it like a grown-up at first. Then, as BJPenn.com reported, he changed course and started insisting he deserved the nod and the belt. Somewhere in there he got into a heated back-and-forth with Jon Jones on social media, because of course he did. Now he’s back at Jackson-Wink MMA and has posted an Instagram message aimed squarely at Dana White and the UFC front office.
“The UFC needs to change the rules in title fights, lock the cage door, until someone gives up,” Hokit said.
He followed it up with this: “There [should be] no decisions in title fights.”
I love this. I also think it’s one of the worst rule proposals I’ve heard from an active fighter, and I want to explain why both of those things can be true at the same time.
The promo is elite
Give Hokit his flowers first. Conor McGregor has said that, setting himself aside, Hokit is the biggest draw in the UFC today. You can argue with McGregor about plenty, but the man knows what moves tickets, and “lock the cage door” moves tickets. It sounds like the tagline on a prison movie poster. Fighters who talk like this are the reason I watch press conferences with the volume cranked, and heavyweight has needed a loudmouth with a real following for a while.
He’s even got a stat that, on paper, matches his energy. According to BJPenn.com, six of the UFC’s 10 title fights in 2026 have gone to the judges, while four ended by TKO or submission. If you hate watching a belt get decided by three people sitting cageside, that ratio stings a little.
The rule is a disaster
Now look at what actually happened at UFC 334. The fight Hokit lost was, by that same outlet’s account, one of the best of the year. It went the distance and still delivered. Nobody walked out of the Garden feeling cheated on entertainment. The only guy who seems to feel cheated is Hokit, and he didn’t even feel that way right away.
And on the same card, the co-main ended with the women’s bantamweight champion submitting Amanda Nunes, a UFC Hall of Famer. Title fights finish when somebody makes them finish. The co-main proved that about an hour before Hokit’s walkout.
Then think about what “until someone gives up” means in practice for heavyweights. Picture two huge men deep into a fight with nothing left in the tank, leaning on each other against the fence, and no bell coming. Best case, it turns into a slow contest of who can stay upright longer. Worst case, a referee has to stand there and watch two exhausted guys soak up damage because the rulebook says nobody gets to go home. Fans would get bored long before anyone tapped, and the broadcast team would be sweating bullets about the clock on a pay-per-view main event with no end time.
I’m a sucker for chaos. I’d still rather have a scorecard than an endurance hostage situation.
The timing tells you everything
Here’s my honest read. A guy who had his hand raised does not wake up the next week demanding the abolition of judges. Hokit went from accepting the result, to claiming he won, to scrapping with Jon Jones online, to calling for a total rewrite of how title fights end. That’s the five stages of grief on a speedrun, with an Instagram caption at the finish line.
And that’s fine! Losing for the first time stinks, and wanting to rage at the system is human. I just won’t pretend the proposal came from anywhere other than a sore spot. If Hokit thinks the judges got it wrong, the fix is to leave them nothing to judge next time.
What happens next
Gane appears headed for a potential rematch with Tom Aspinall in his next title defense, per BJPenn.com, which means Hokit will likely have to win at least one more fight before he can make a real case for another shot. Good. That’s his actual lock-the-cage-door moment. Pick a ranked heavyweight, walk him down, and make the scorecards irrelevant the old-fashioned way. If McGregor’s right and Hokit really is the second-biggest draw in the company, the UFC will give him a fight that matters. Skip the rulebook. Go get a stoppage.





