Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Analysis

Ciryl Gane Just Defended The UFC Heavyweight Title And Still Isn't MMA's No. 1

Tom Aspinall, who hasn't returned since Gane's eye poke ended their UFC 321 fight, kept the top spot on a split MMA Fighting panel where Gane and Aspinall drew two first-place votes each and Francis Ngannou took the fifth.

Ciryl Gane
Photo: Ciryl Gane: The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Ciryl Gane left UFC 334 with a unanimous decision over Josh Hokit, a belt the UFC had already handed him in September, and one odd distinction. He’s a defending champion who still can’t win over a five-person ranking panel. MMA Fighting’s Global Rankings came out Friday, and Tom Aspinall is still sitting at No. 1 at heavyweight.

The vote was about as split as a five-person vote can get. Aspinall drew two first-place votes. Gane drew two. Francis Ngannou, the lineal champ, picked up the fifth. Gane went into UFC 334 ranked No. 2, beat the No. 6 guy in the division, and came out ranked No. 2. A win over a top-six opponent in a title fight moved him zero spots, which is the kind of number that makes me want to check the math twice.

I’ve checked it. My position: Gane should be No. 1 right now, and the arguments keeping him off the top line are older than they look.

The case against Gane, taken seriously

The skeptics have real material, so let’s lay it out. Ngannou beat Gane in their 2022 championship fight. Head-to-head results are the best tiebreaker in rankings, and that one goes against the Frenchman. The panel also flagged Gane’s flat performances against Jon Jones and Alexander Volkov in recent years, two nights when he fought for a title or a title shot and didn’t look like the best heavyweight on the planet.

Then there’s the strange route to the belt. His second crack at the undisputed title, against Aspinall at UFC 321, ended inconclusively when Gane poked Aspinall in the eyes and Aspinall couldn’t continue. Aspinall needed surgery. Gane then got an interim title fight against Alex Pereira at UFC White House, a booking that looked built to hand Pereira a shot at becoming the UFC’s first three-division champion. Gane knocked him out in Round 2, and Pereira has disputed how it went down. In September, with no return date for Aspinall, the UFC promoted Gane to undisputed. Every step comes with an asterisk somebody can point at.

Why it doesn’t hold up

Now look at what the other two guys have done lately, because rankings are supposed to measure current form.

Ngannou’s 2022 win over Gane is real, and it’s also four calendar years old. His most recent win came against Philipe Lins, whom MMA Fighting described as a UFC washout. If you’re holding a lineal claim on the strength of a Lins win, you’re cashing a ticket from a race that ran in 2022.

Aspinall’s position bugs me more. His last fight is the one against Gane that produced no winner. He’s No. 1 on a ballot off a result that, by definition, told us nothing about who’s better. And the panel’s own rules put a clock on him: fighters get removed automatically after 18 months without competing, which means Aspinall drops off entirely if he doesn’t fight by April. A No. 1 with a built-in expiration date is a placeholder with good PR.

Gane, meanwhile, has two results in a row against ranked opposition. He stopped Pereira. Then he took everything Hokit threw at him, a relentless assault by MMA Fighting’s description, and still out-struck him convincingly over the full distance. That’s the version of Gane people kept saying didn’t exist, the one who can absorb pressure and keep his shape. If I’m pricing these three on what they’ve shown in their last two fights, Gane is the clear favorite, and it isn’t particularly close.

The Jones and Volkov nights count against him. Fine. They also happened before the two most recent wins on his record, and recency should carry weight on a list built around who’s best today.

The fine print

MMA Fighting is upfront that holding a promotional belt doesn’t automatically make someone the best fighter in that promotion in its eyes. Fair rule. I’d just apply it consistently, and an inactive fighter coming off an inconclusive bout shouldn’t get the benefit of the doubt over an active champion coming off back-to-back wins. The outlet itself joked that Gane could soon be No. 1 by default, calling that “the sexiest way to become recognized as the best in your field.” Funny line. The default scenario also happens to be the correct answer, just arriving five months late.

The rest of the division keeps moving while this gets sorted. Volkov, ranked No. 4, beat Rizvan Kuniev. Johnny Walker jumped to No. 8 after knocking out Waldo Cortes-Acosta in the UFC Vegas 124 main event, and he’s already calling for Hokit. And the guy who still disputes his loss to Gane, Pereira, fights No. 5 Sergei Pavlovich at heavyweight at UFC 335 on Dec. 12. If Pereira wins that one, the rematch talk writes itself, and Gane would get the chance to remove one more asterisk with his hands.

Aspinall’s deadline is April. Either he comes back and settles it with Gane in the cage, or the rulebook settles it for him.

Keep reading