Ilia Topuria hasn’t fought since June, when Justin Gaethje took his lightweight title in the UFC Freedom 250 main event and sent him home with two broken orbital bones. Topuria has said he came close to needing surgery that would have ended his career. That’s the backdrop for Joe Rogan’s latest podcast take, which Bloody Elbow picked up this week. Rogan thinks the 29-year-old Spaniard should go back to featherweight, where he says Topuria belongs.
I’m a numbers guy who rarely takes career advice from a podcast. I’m signing this one.
Rogan’s Diagnosis Holds Up
Rogan didn’t trash Topuria. He described a fighter who was head and shoulders above everybody, with efficient movement, real power and the kind of discipline that dials everything in for a camp. Then he named the hole: “he’d just never been in the trenches.” Gaethje dragged him there, and the size gap made the trenches deeper.
“Gaethje’s bigger than him, like quite a bit bigger than him,” Rogan said, adding that Gaethje is “a big 155lber and Ilia is not.”
That isn’t a hot take. Topuria was never considered a big featherweight to begin with, which is why his jump to 155 surprised people when he announced it. He moved up a division as a guy who didn’t even have size on the field in the division he left.
His reasons made sense on paper. Topuria said he was done suffering through the cut, and after winning the featherweight title he felt there was nothing left for him to do there. I’ve done enough dumb things to lose 10 pounds that I’m sympathetic. But he swapped one miserable week before fight night for 25 minutes against men who rehydrate into a different time zone.
Rogan’s point on weight cutting is the part I’d circle in red. Topuria cuts to make 155, sure. Plenty of the guys across from him are cutting a lot more.
“It’s guys who could never make 145lbs and they’re cutting barely down to 155lbs and they’re huge, you know?” Rogan said.
In other words, the lightweight version of Topuria is the smaller man on a lot of fight nights, and he just found out what that costs over a long fight against someone who won’t go away.
The Price Problem
This is where my day job comes in. Bettors anchor to the last version of a fighter they fell in love with. With Topuria, that’s the guy Rogan described, the clean, powerful, confident finisher who looked untouchable. The market will remember that guy for a while.
The guy who actually shows up next is coming off his first loss, coming off two fractured orbitals, and coming off a layoff that runs from June to a targeted return in the first quarter of 2027. That’s seven months minimum, and the reason for the layoff is that his face got broken in two places. You already know how I feel about laying short odds on fighters returning from long layoffs. Add facial fractures and a weight class that a guy who calls these fights for a living says is wrong for him, and I don’t want any part of the favorite side.
The rematch Topuria keeps asking for looks dead anyway. He’s been campaigning for an immediate second fight with Gaethje, and the champion has shown no interest. Bloody Elbow notes that Paddy Pimblett is the more likely next opponent, since the Englishman has been turning up the heat on his pursuit of Topuria.
I’m not claiming Pimblett is Gaethje. I’m saying a Topuria vs. Pimblett fight at 155 is the kind of matchup that sells, gets hyped hard, and comes with a line built on reputation instead of the most recent evidence. That’s a spot where I watch the number and keep my wallet closed.
The Counterargument, and Why It’s Thin
The case for staying at lightweight is pride. Topuria left 145 because he’d conquered it. Going back after a loss can look like a retreat.
I’d frame it differently. He now has something left to prove at featherweight, which is the exact thing he said he lacked when he left. A champion coming back to reclaim his old division after his first defeat is a better story than a small lightweight getting thrown into the next physical mismatch. It’s also the better bet.
Rogan left the door open himself. “I think with Ilia, at 145lbs, it’s a much better weight class for him,” he said. “But I’m interested to see when he comes back and how he rebounds from something like that.”
So am I. The target is early 2027, the opponent is still unsigned, and if the contract says 155 and Pimblett, I’ll be studying the opening line long before I watch the hype video.





