Islam Makhachev doesn’t do diplomacy, and he certainly doesn’t do it for Nate Diaz.
Asked about a potential MMA fight between Jake Paul and Diaz, the man Ali Abdelaziz keeps calling the number one pound-for-pound fighter in the world sided with Paul, and his reasoning was about as subtle as a body lock against the cage. Per Yardbarker, Makhachev’s verdict on Diaz was blunt: ‘This guy is not in good shape now.’ He backed Paul’s physical condition over Diaz’s, which is a sentence I never expected to type about a Dagestani wrestler and a YouTuber.
My take is simple. Makhachev is probably right, and that should make everyone a little nervous about this fight actually happening.
View post on X
Why Makhachev’s Opinion Lands
Plenty of people have opinions on Jake Paul. Most of them are yelling into a microphone. Makhachev’s opinion matters because of who’s attached to him. Abdelaziz spent Wednesday and Thursday on X running a victory lap for his roster, listing Makhachev as the pound-for-pound number one and a double champion, Kayla Harrison as the women’s pound-for-pound number one, plus Kamaru Usman, Khabib Nurmagomedov, Henry Cejudo and Justin Gaethje. He told the haters to look at the results. Fair enough. When a guy from that room tells you someone looks out of shape, he’s grading conditioning against the hardest standard in the sport.
And here’s what I love about it. Makhachev didn’t say Paul is a better fighter. He didn’t say Diaz forgot how to throw the 1-2 or lost his jiu-jitsu. He made a narrower, nastier point, which is that one of these guys looks ready and the other one doesn’t. That’s the kind of take that ages well, because it’s about the body, and bodies don’t lie for 15 minutes.
Paul Is Courting the Dagestan Crowd
The Makhachev endorsement doesn’t come out of nowhere. Paul has spent the week flirting with that entire camp. In a clip he posted, flagged by Championship Rounds and Happy Punch, Paul asked Khabib when he was coming back and floated $200M to get him out of retirement. Then, according to Happy Punch, he tried to wrestle him. Jake Paul trying to wrestle Khabib Nurmagomedov is the most Jake Paul thing to happen this calendar year, and that’s a crowded field.
Khabib shut it down with a line that should be framed in every promoter’s office: “Why I have to come back? Nothing to prove. There is no opponent, only money. It’s not motivation for me.”
View post on X
Read that again with Paul vs. Diaz in MMA in mind. There is no opponent, only money. That’s the risk with this matchup. If Makhachev’s read is accurate and Diaz shows up as a guy cashing a check instead of a guy who’s been grinding rounds, fans get a pay-per-view priced like a title fight and a performance priced like a hangover. I love a big-money crossover. I can’t stand being treated like an ATM. Those two feelings collide right here.
Paul Is Actually Busy
Meanwhile, Paul’s calendar backs up the “he’s in shape” argument better than any quote could. Most Valuable Promotions announced Thursday that Paul faces Cédric Doumbé on Thursday, December 24, at Coca-Cola Arena in Dubai. The card has real depth too: Chantelle Cameron vs. Mikaela Mayer for the unified super welterweight world championship, Alistair Overeem vs. Jimi Manuwa at heavyweight, and Jahmal Harvey vs. Craig Morgan, with more fights promised.
Say what you want about Paul, but he keeps booking dates. A guy with a fight on Christmas Eve is a guy in a training camp right now. That’s the gap Makhachev was pointing at. Paul is in the gym because he has to be. Nobody has told me Diaz has a date on the calendar, and until that changes, the conditioning question is fair game.
The Catch
I’ll give Diaz this much. Being out of shape in November isn’t a permanent condition. If a Paul fight under MMA rules ever gets signed, Diaz would get a camp, and a motivated Diaz is a different animal from whatever Makhachev saw. The problem is that motivation was the entire subject of Khabib’s answer to Paul, and it’s the one thing money can’t buy at any price, $200M or otherwise.
View post on X
So where does that leave us? Makhachev picked Paul, and on the evidence available he picked correctly. Paul is active, he’s surrounded by elite people he keeps trying to recruit or grapple, and he’s got a real opponent in Doumbé in five weeks. Diaz has a pound-for-pound king publicly questioning his shape.
If Nate wants to make Makhachev eat those words, the move is obvious. Get a date, show up lean, and make the Paul MMA fight feel like a fight instead of an invoice. Until then, the only date that matters is December 24 in Dubai, and Paul’s the one with a reason to be in shape for it.





