Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Bryce Mitchell Torches Daniel Cormier Over UFC 334 Calls and Swears Josh Hokit Won

Mitchell scored Rounds 1 through 4 for Hokit and told Cormier on Instagram that he has no business calling the score mid-fight.

Commentator headset resting on a cageside broadcast desk beside a glowing monitor during a UFC event

Bryce Mitchell watched Josh Hokit lose a heavyweight title fight Saturday night and came away mad at the guy wearing the headset. He’s half right, and he picked the better half to be right about.

Quick recap for anyone who slept through it. At UFC 334 in New York, Hokit challenged Ciryl Gane for the heavyweight belt, and Gane walked out with a unanimous decision that Yahoo Sports described as closely contested, with Gane outclassing Hokit on the feet. The main event picked up a bonus. Daniel Cormier was on commentary. Mitchell, the UFC bantamweight, went to Instagram afterward and unloaded on the judges and on DC in the same breath.

The Scorecard Take Falls Apart on Contact

Start with Mitchell’s scoring, because that’s where he loses me.

“Josh Hokit won that fight... I don’t care what nobody says,” Mitchell said. “The forward aggression wins a fight. Maybe Gane landed a little bit more punches, especially in the fifth round. But I gave Hokit one through four…”

Read that back slowly. The man arguing Hokit got robbed concedes, in his own clip, that Gane landed more. That’s the whole case for Gane, delivered by the prosecution. Under the unified rules, effective striking and grappling sit at the top of the criteria and aggression only comes into play once those are even. Marching forward wins you the crowd. It doesn’t win you a round when the guy backing up is the one landing. Mitchell scored this one with his gut, and his gut apparently thinks pressure counts double.

MMA Sucka’s headline had him calling the decision rigged, which is a big word to hang on a fight where you admit the other guy outlanded your guy. Then there’s my favorite line of the whole rant: “Hokit is the most exciting heavyweight there has ever been… After watching Hokit fight, I’m not watching these other guys fight.”

One fight, and Bryce has unsubscribed from an entire weight class. I respect the commitment. I’d still bet he’s watching the next heavyweight main event like everybody else.

The Commentary Take Lands Clean

Now the part where Mitchell is dead on.

“I’m getting tired of DC, in the middle of a fight, insinuating he knows who is winning,” Mitchell said. “As a commentator, you don’t know who is winning.”

He followed that with the line Sherdog put at the top of its post: “You’re not a judge.”

That’s correct, and it matters more in a fight like this one. A blowout doesn’t need anyone to call the score. A close five-rounder for the heavyweight title is exactly where the booth should be explaining what’s happening (who’s landing, who’s controlling range, who’s fading) and leaving the math to the three people paid to do it. According to Mitchell, Cormier spent the night doing the opposite. In Mitchell’s telling, DC was saying round after round that Gane was up and Hokit was losing. That’s Mitchell’s paraphrase of the broadcast, so take the exact wording with a grain of salt, but the complaint is clear.

Here’s why it bugs me. Cormier is a Hall of Famer and a former two-division champion. When he says somebody’s ahead, viewers at home don’t hear an opinion. They hear a verdict from the most credentialed voice in the building. Half the audience starts scoring along with him. So when the cards come back for Gane, nobody’s surprised, and the guy who thought Hokit was winning feels like he was watching a different fight because the broadcast told him he was wrong for an hour.

The funny twist is that DC’s read landed. Gane got the decision. Being right still doesn’t make it the job, though. The play-by-play guy doesn’t get to call a fight early because he’s confident about who’s winning either.

Yahoo noted that Cormier’s commentary keeps drawing backlash, and this one comes with a ready-made fix. Mitchell even wrote the script for him: “He could be winning; it’s a very close fight.” That’s it. That sentence is honest, it keeps the tension alive, and it doesn’t make a challenger’s family feel like the broadcast buried him before the fifth round started. A bantamweight on Instagram shouldn’t be out-producing the UFC’s top color man, but here we are.

Mitchell also said flat out, “I don’t want to hear that sh*t,” which is less diplomatic than my version but hits the same spot.

So here’s the split decision. Mitchell’s scorecard goes in the trash, since you can’t admit your guy got outlanded and then call it a robbery. His shot at Cormier deserves a full replay. Gane keeps the belt, Hokit keeps the bonus money and at least one bantamweight’s undying loyalty, and DC keeps the headset. If he wants to keep the scorecards too, the New York commission is right there with a pencil.

Keep reading