Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Amanda Nunes Wants Kayla Harrison Again Right Now, and It's the Worst Idea on the Table

Harrison submitted Nunes in the UFC 334 co-main at Madison Square Garden, and the Lioness is already demanding a featherweight rematch in 2027.

Amanda Nunes Wants Kayla Harrison Again Right Now, and It's the Worst Idea on the Table

Amanda Nunes lost to Kayla Harrison by submission on November 14 at Madison Square Garden, in the co-main event of UFC 334, and within days she was back on social media demanding a do-over. She wants it at featherweight. She wants it in 2027. She says Harrison doesn’t get to decide. “We’re going to make this happen,” Nunes said, in a clip bjpenn.com posted to X.

I love the confidence. I hate the plan, mostly because I haven’t heard one.

A rematch only makes sense if the second fight looks different from the first, and nothing Nunes has said publicly suggests she’s thinking about the problem that beat her. She’s thinking about the fact that she lost. Those are two very different things to bring into a training camp.

The game plan was the problem

The criticism of Nunes since UFC 334 has centered on one decision, and it’s the right decision to criticize. As Bloody Elbow noted, she initiated grappling exchanges with Harrison. Harrison is a two-time Olympic gold medalist in judo. Choosing to start the grappling against her is like challenging a sprinter to a footrace because you’re a decent jogger and you feel good today.

This is what bothers me most. Nunes and Harrison were teammates at American Top Team in Coconut Creek, Florida. Nunes has felt Harrison’s grips. She knows how heavy that top game is, how the chain wrestling keeps coming after the first attempt gets stuffed, how one failed sprawl turns into a body lock and the body lock turns into a mat return. Nobody on the roster had better scouting on Harrison than the woman who walked straight into her strength anyway.

So when Nunes says “This is not PFL, baby,” as Sherdog reported, my honest reaction is that she’s right, and it didn’t help her one bit. The Octagon was a UFC Octagon on November 14 too. Harrison still got the finish.

What an actual adjustment looks like

If Nunes wants this fight to be worth booking, here’s the homework. First, she has to commit to fighting at range and making Harrison pay on the entry, which means stance discipline, a real sprawl, and the willingness to look boring for long stretches while she waits for the shot to come to her. Second, she needs a cage plan. Harrison’s wrestling gets nastier when an opponent is pinned on the fence, so Nunes has to circle off before the clinch locks up, and if it does lock up, she has to win the underhook battle and get her back off the wall instead of fishing for a trip of her own. Third, and this is the unglamorous one, she needs get-ups. Not a scramble she hopes for. A drilled, repeatable route back to her feet that she’s run a thousand times against bigger training partners.

None of that is exciting. All of it is required. A legend making real adjustments between fights is my favorite thing in this sport, and I’d happily eat my words if she shows up having rebuilt her grappling defense from the floor up.

The best case for an immediate rematch

The strongest counterargument goes like this: Nunes is the consensus greatest women’s fighter in UFC history, she only needs to land once, and a fight at 145 pounds gives her more room to work. Puncher’s equity is real, and legends have earned the benefit of the doubt.

Except puncher’s equity requires being on your feet with your hands free. A clean shot is useless from bottom position with an Olympic judoka’s chest on yours, and moving up to featherweight doesn’t shrink Harrison’s grappling. If anything, a few extra pounds on everyone makes the top pressure heavier. Banking on a home run swing is fine when the other fighter has to come into your range. Harrison doesn’t have to do that. She proved she can get the fight where she wants it, and the loser of that fight doesn’t get to assume the next one starts somewhere else.

One Bloody Elbow reader put it better than half the pundits I’ve read this week: “I’d give her another chance against Kayla at the higher weight. If she cannot show more sense, then Dana should retire her.” That’s the correct framing. The rematch has to be earned with sense, not with seniority.

Harrison’s other option

Nunes also scoffed at Harrison entertaining a superfight with Valentina Shevchenko instead of running it back, MMA Junkie reported, and she has accused Harrison of going back on a rematch promise made at the UFC 334 pre-fight press conference. If Harrison did offer that, Nunes has a fair gripe on etiquette. Etiquette doesn’t decide matchmaking, though, and it definitely doesn’t stop a body lock.

My take is simple. If Nunes can show the UFC a version of herself built to stay off the fence and get up off the mat, book the featherweight rematch for 2027 and I’ll be first in line. If the plan is to walk forward and hope the right hand finds a home before Harrison finds a grip, the UFC shouldn’t book it, and Nunes shouldn’t want it.