Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Joe Rogan Calls Ciryl Gane's Free Eye Poke 'Crazy' and He's Dead Right

After UFC 334, Rogan said fingers extended toward the eyes should cost a point every time, and he pointed to Tom Aspinall's four surgeries as the reason.

A referee's hand separating two fighters' MMA gloves, one with fingers extended

Joe Rogan has seen enough of Ciryl Gane’s lead hand to stop being polite about it. On his podcast this week, Rogan said Gane’s uncalled eye poke on Josh Hokit at UFC 334 should have cost the heavyweight champion a point. Then he went further. Any fighter who sticks open fingers out toward an opponent’s face should lose a point, the same way you would for grabbing the fence.

He’s right. And Gane is the cleanest case study you could ask for.

Quick recap. Saturday’s main event was 25 minutes of two heavyweights trying to break each other, and Gane kept his belt on the scorecards. Hokit pressured him so relentlessly that, by Rogan’s read, Gane was gassing in Round 1 because he had no room to find his rhythm. Hokit has since taken to social media to question the judging, push for an immediate rematch and point out that Gane caught him in the eye. No point came off. Rogan’s reaction: “He didn’t even get fined a point, which I thought was crazy.”

The Gane File

If this were a one-off, I’d shrug and move on. It isn’t. At UFC 321, Gane poked then-champion Tom Aspinall in the eye and the fight ended on the spot because Aspinall couldn’t continue. Gane then knocked out Alex Pereira at UFC White House to win the interim belt (Pereira has since complained about illegal blows to the head during that finish), and in September Gane was promoted to undisputed champion while Aspinall was still recovering from his eye injuries.

Read that sequence one more time. The guy who got fouled lost his belt. The guy who fouled him is wearing it. Rogan put it about as bluntly as a man can: “You can fck a guy’s whole career up. Look at Aspinall. Four fcking surgeries.” That is what a warning buys you. The referee tells a fighter to watch the hands, the fight resumes, and a champion ends up needing four surgeries and giving up his title.

Rogan Drew the Right Line

What I like about Rogan’s argument is that he drew a real distinction instead of screaming for the death penalty on every accidental graze. He separated accidents from habits. If a guy dives forward and his face runs into your hand, Rogan said, that can happen. He gave nut kicks a similar pass, because legs clash and shots glance off a moving target. His problem is the reaching, open-handed frame. He noted it’s normal in Muay Thai, where the gloves cover the fingers, and it turns ugly with MMA gloves. His words: “You just can’t extend your hand towards someone’s eyes. That’s a point.”

That’s the entire case, honestly. You can’t accidentally point your fingers at a man’s face over and over. That habit gets built in the gym long before it shows up in a title fight. Rogan compared it to grabbing the fence, a foul you only commit on purpose because you know it’s illegal. A fighter who keeps shoving out open fingers knows exactly what he’s doing too.

And Gane doesn’t need the shortcut. Rogan gave him real credit for the back half of the Hokit fight, saying Gane settled in during Rounds 4 and 5, caught his second wind, and started landing knees to the body and a pile of kicks. That’s a heavyweight champion with elite footwork solving a problem the hard way. Which makes the hand thing more annoying, because he’s good enough to win without it.

Stop It and Look

The other half of Rogan’s pitch is practical, and it answers the usual excuse. Referees hate taking points because they don’t want to decide a championship fight. Fair. But Rogan said a fighter with Gane’s history earns a pause in the action, and the Hokit poke happened during ordinary standup. Nobody was hurt. Nobody had a submission locked in. Stopping it would have cost zero momentum. “Stop it. Take a look.”

Here’s my problem with the cautious referee. In a five-round title fight that goes to the cards, with the loser already campaigning for a rematch, an uncalled foul decides things too. It just does it quietly, where nobody has to own it. A deducted point at least puts the decision out in the open with a name attached.

Rogan isn’t alone on this, either. Tommy McMillen, sitting across from him on the podcast, said flatly, “That was such a bad eye poke, that should’ve been a point. That was bad.” Rogan’s answer was “100%.”

Hokit wants the rematch, and he’s lobbying hard for it to happen right away. If the UFC books it, the referee assigned to that fight should walk into the cage already knowing what happens the first time Gane’s fingers drift toward Hokit’s face. One point. No speech.

Keep reading