Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Demetrious Johnson Torched Gane vs. Hokit While Everyone Else Was Throwing a Party

Watching live on his YouTube channel, Mighty Mouse said he'd rather watch K-1 kickboxing than the UFC 334 heavyweight title fight that won Fight of the Night.

Ciryl Gane and Josh Hokit
Photo: Ciryl Gane: The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons | Josh Hokit: U.S. Army photo by Sgt. 1st Class Brittany Primavera, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Saturday night at Madison Square Garden, 20,000 people and a whole lot of people at home were screaming at a heavyweight title fight. Demetrious Johnson was screaming too, just in the other direction.

Ciryl Gane kept his belt after five rounds of slugging with Josh Hokit in the UFC 334 main event. The fight took home Fight of the Night, Dana White called it a “street fight” afterward, and it’s already being filed alongside the most memorable scraps of the year. Johnson, streaming his live reactions on his YouTube channel, watched the same 25 minutes and came away feeling personally betrayed.

“What are we watching right now?” Johnson said, per Bloody Elbow’s rundown of the stream. “Where is the athleticism? Where is the explosiveness? Where are the body kicks?” He followed that up by saying he’d rather watch K-1 kickboxing, and later, as Gane kept passing on knees early, he landed on the line that’s now bouncing around everywhere: “I am so disappointed.”

My take: Mighty Mouse is right about Gane and wrong about the fight. Both of those things can live in the same building.

Johnson nailed the problem

The specific complaint Johnson raised was sharp. He kept pointing at Gane backing away from Hokit’s pressure instead of doing something about it, like tying him up in the clinch and making the challenger pay for walking forward. That’s the right diagnosis. Hokit came in with a plan to march Gane down and make him fight at Hokit’s pace, and the plan worked well enough that the two of them spent long stretches standing in the pocket trading punches.

That’s a problem for the champion. Gane is supposed to be the slick one. He’s the heavyweight with Muay Thai in his bones, the guy who’s spent his whole career living on the outside and picking people apart from range. Johnson wanted to see the knees and the body kicks that should punish a man who keeps stepping into your space, and for a big chunk of the fight they just weren’t there.

When a fighter as technical as Johnson (arguably the most complete technician the sport has ever produced) watches a title fight and asks where the skill went, I’m inclined to listen. This is a guy who breaks down technique on his channel as a hobby. He knows what a champion leaving weapons in the bag looks like.

The fight itself was a blast, though

Here’s where I get off the Mighty Mouse bus. “Horrible” is a wild word for a fight that held a sold out Garden for five rounds. The pace those two heavyweights kept was absurd, and a heavyweight title fight that never sags is about as rare as a quiet Conor McGregor press conference.

There’s also a decent explanation for why Gane fought the way he did. Bloody Elbow pointed out that Gane has always wanted space, and throwing knees and kicks against a guy like Hokit opens the door to getting taken down. Gane’s takedown defense held up throughout the fight, and as the rounds wore on he started mixing in more varied strikes. That reads less like a man who forgot how to fight and more like a champion who decided staying on his feet mattered more than looking pretty.

And honestly, I’ll take a champion who gets dragged into a phone booth and wins over one who coasts on a jab for 25 minutes and wins. I’ve sat through enough boring title defenses where the belt holder plays it safe and the crowd starts booing by the third round. Gane got pulled into the other guy’s fight and found a way through it. That counts for something.

This keeps happening

Johnson isn’t alone in this lane. Josh Barnett had similar gripes about Justin Gaethje vs. Paddy Pimblett, another fight a lot of people loved and some fighters felt was missing finesse. There’s a real split between what fighters admire and what fans pay for, and the UFC’s bonus checks tend to side with the fans.

I don’t think either side is crazy. Fighters see openings that never get used. Fans see two guys throwing leather and lose their minds. Both reactions are honest.

Where Johnson’s critique should actually land is on the next Gane defense. If Hokit could walk him down and dictate the terms, every heavyweight with a chin and a gas tank just watched the blueprint. The bonus money is in the bank and the belt is still around Gane’s waist, but if he lets the next challenger set the pace like that, Mighty Mouse won’t be the only one asking where the body kicks went.

Sources: Bloody Elbow

Keep reading