Next UFC Fight Night: Procházka vs. Stirling, Sat, Nov 21 (Procházka vs. Stirling)Results UFC 334Ciryl Gane def. Josh HokitKayla Harrison def. Amanda NunesCaio Borralho def. Yousri BelgarouiLuis Gurule def. Bilal HasanStephen Thompson def. Charles Radtke
Opinion

Ciryl Gane's UFC 334 Eye Poke Has an Ex-Champ Fuming and Hokit Demanding a Rematch

Josh Hokit says Gane poked his eye out 40 seconds into the fight, Sean O'Malley says a point should have come off the scorecard, and Hokit wants it run back.

Ciryl Gane and Josh Hokit
Photo: Ciryl Gane: The White House, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons | Josh Hokit: U.S. Army photo by Sgt. 1st Class Brittany Primavera, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Forty seconds. That’s how long Josh Hokit says he got to see clearly at UFC 334 before Ciryl Gane’s fingers ended up in his eye. Everything after that, he fought half-blind against one of the slickest heavyweight strikers alive, and he still walked away convinced he won. I’m here to tell you the eye poke deserves a lot more attention than it got on fight night, and the people raising hell about it have a point.

The pile-on has been building all week. MMA Junkie ran with the headline that an ex-champion was making a big deal of Gane’s early poke, and MMA Sucka had its own version with a former UFC champion weighing the risks of it. Sean O’Malley got there first, on Sunday, and he didn’t bother with nuance.

“Just because the ref didn’t see it, it doesn’t count? It could’ve completely changed that fight. Clear eye poke and needed to take a point… UFC needs to take action. How is it that confusing?” O’Malley said, via Happy Punch.

Read that first line again, because that’s the whole problem in 12 words. If O’Malley’s read is right, the referee missed it, so in the official record of UFC 334 it basically didn’t happen. No pause, no warning, no point deduction. One guy gets a free shot to the eyeball in the opening minute of a heavyweight fight and the bout rolls on like somebody spilled a drink in the third row.

Hokit’s Side of It

Hokit laid out his version on X on Tuesday, tagging the UFC and Dana White directly. “He completely poked my eye out 40 secs into the fight,” he wrote. “I complained and got no help.”

That second sentence is the one that bugs me. A fighter getting poked is bad luck. A fighter getting poked, telling the ref, and getting nothing back is a system failure. Hokit went on to say that being blinded gave him every excuse to walk away and blow up the event, and that he chose to keep going for the fans. “I’m not a bitch,” he added, which is about as Hokit as a sentence gets.

Now, am I taking a man’s word at face value when he’s openly campaigning for a rematch? No. Hokit closed that same post by saying “Most people know I won that night” and arguing they should run it back. He has every incentive to make the poke sound like it ripped his retina out. Fighters always remember the foul as worse than it looked.

Here’s where his case gets stronger, though. He didn’t fold. Robert Whittaker, talking on the MMArcade Podcast, described Hokit walking Gane down like somebody was controlling him with a PlayStation controller from the couch. Whittaker said Hokit had zero respect for Gane’s power, took “four billion shots,” and turned it into his fight. That’s a guy with a compromised eye eating Gane’s best stuff and marching forward anyway. You can think Hokit is a lunatic (he kind of is) and still admit that’s the type of performance that earns you a second look at what went wrong in the first minute.

Why This Should Bother Everybody

My issue goes beyond Gane. I’m not calling him a dirty fighter on the strength of one disputed sequence, and the sources don’t give me a pattern to point to. My issue is the rule that a foul only exists if the referee happens to catch it from the right angle in real time. We have a dozen camera angles on every Octagon. We have replays slowed down to the frame within seconds of the poke landing. The broadcast audience at home can see a finger go into an eye better than the one official standing six feet away, and the guy getting poked has zero recourse if that official was looking at the wrong hand.

O’Malley asking how it’s that confusing is fair. It isn’t confusing. A clear foul with an effect on the fight should cost something. If the point O’Malley wanted taken had come off, we might be talking about a different scorecard right now, and that’s exactly why it matters.

The Hokit circus doesn’t help him look sympathetic. He spent the weekend in a gross, personal back-and-forth with Jon Jones that I’m not repeating here, and Conor McGregor jumped into his corner on X, calling Hokit “the biggest draw in the ufc today” outside of himself and welcoming him to Paradigm Sports with a “CONTRACTMAXXING 101” hashtag. That’s a lot of noise around a fighter who already lives at full volume. None of it changes what happened 40 seconds in.

The UFC loves Hokit’s energy when he’s selling weigh-ins and press conferences. Fine. Then take his complaint seriously too. Pull the tape on the poke, put out a real answer on why nothing was called, and if the footage looks the way O’Malley says it does, book Gane vs. Hokit 2 and let the man fight with two working eyes this time.

Keep reading