I’m settling the barstool argument up front. Ciryl Gane vs. Josh Hokit at UFC 334 was a blast to watch, and it was also kind of a mess, and I’m completely comfortable holding both of those opinions at once. Where it gets interesting is what each guy should do next, because how you label that fight decides how you book the sequel.
Ben Fowlkes put it cleanly in his Yahoo Sports mailbag this week: “all good fights are fun fights, but not all fun fights are good fights.” He compared the Madison Square Garden main event to two guys “scrapping it out like a couple stray cats in the alley at midnight,” and he’s right. One of his readers pointed out that DJ called the main event awful while Michael Bisping called it entertaining. Fowlkes’ answer amounted to this: both former champs can be correct, because some fans want a slobber-knocker and some want a grappling chess match.
I’m in the slobber-knocker camp, for the record. I love chaos. But the label still matters.
View post on X
Gane won, and the fight he needs is obvious
Fowlkes went back and rewatched the whole thing with the commentary muted to re-score it, and he still had Gane winning. Gane left New York with the UFC heavyweight title. MMA Fighting’s Mike Heck and Alexander K. Lee called it a Fight of the Year contender on their On To the Next One show. Great. Now please, nobody pitch me an immediate rematch.
The fight for Gane is Tom Aspinall, and Fowlkes laid out why better than anyone. Of the guys currently on the roster, Aspinall vs. Gane is the only heavyweight fight that feels like the No. 1 seed against the No. 2 seed. It’s the biggest fight the division can make without re-signing Francis Ngannou or dragging Jon Jones out of retirement. Then there’s the revenge angle, which I’d put on a plaque. Aspinall’s career and his vision were put in jeopardy because of Gane’s fingers, an illegal foul, and if he makes it back he’ll have spent months, maybe years, wondering whether he’d ever live a normal life again.
You know how much I hate manufactured beef that dies the second two guys stand nose to nose at the face-off. This is the opposite. Nobody has to fake anything. Aspinall has every reason to want to hurt this man, and MMA is the one sport that pays you for doing it.
The catch is the “if.” Fowlkes wrote “if and when” about Aspinall’s return, and that phrasing is doing a lot of work. If Aspinall can’t go soon, Gane needs to defend the belt against somebody instead of sitting on it. A champion parked on the couch waiting for the perfect payday is my least favorite genre of heavyweight.
Hokit is real, but slow down a little
Hokit is the guy who actually won the weekend. MMA Fighting described him as leaving MSG a made guy in the division and in the promotion as a whole, which is a wild thing to say about a man who just lost a title fight. MMA Sucka reported that Bisping explained why he believes Hokit can become champion, and the former middleweight king doesn’t hand out that kind of endorsement to everybody.
I buy the ceiling. I’m less sold on the timeline, and Fowlkes gave me the ammo. One of his readers said it felt like Hokit won from inside the arena, while the TV crowd leaned Gane. Fowlkes pointed out that pre-fight expectations bend what we see. When a guy you expected to get smoked looks way better than expected, you start scoring the surprise instead of the punches. Judges literally get warned about this; Fowlkes called them “sympathy rounds.”
That’s a big part of the Hokit glow right now. He beat expectations and didn’t beat Gane. So the smart move is to build him against ranked heavyweights and let him stack wins on the same platform, which his name value now earns him. Rushing him back into a title fight off a loss would be the UFC treating fans like ATMs, and I’ve seen that movie enough times to know how it ends.
The Jones sideshow helps exactly one guy
One more thing about Hokit’s stock: the online war with Jon Jones. Fowlkes called it increasingly ugly and couldn’t figure out what Jones gets out of it, since Jones says he’s retired and has zero interest in fighting in the UFC again. For Hokit, though, it’s free rent in the headlines next to one of the greatest of all time.
So here’s my ruling. Gane gets Aspinall the moment Aspinall can stand across from him. Hokit gets a ranked heavyweight and a chance to prove Bisping right. And Jones, retired and typing, keeps doing unpaid promo work for the guy who just lost at the Garden.





