Amanda Nunes told UFC News that her return “was meant to be,” and I believe she believes it. Fate makes a lovely walkout soundtrack. It does very little against a two-time Olympic judo champion with an underhook, which is what Nunes gets in the UFC 334 co-main event at Madison Square Garden on Saturday.
Nobody needs a refresher on the résumé, but the details matter here. Nunes is the only woman to hold UFC belts in two divisions at the same time and the only fighter of either gender to defend both. She has 23 wins in 28 fights, 13 of them by knockout. She beat Ronda Rousey, Cris Cyborg and Valentina Shevchenko, lost to Julianna Pena, then took the belt back at UFC 277 before her last fight against Irene Aldana. She told Yahoo Sports she walked away because she had cleaned out both divisions, and that Harrison’s arrival in the UFC is what made her want to do this again.
So here’s the fight. Nunes is 38 and three years removed from competition. Harrison is 36, a two-time PFL lightweight champion who won the UFC bantamweight title in only her third fight with the promotion. The bout was supposed to happen in January before Harrison needed neck and spinal surgery. They’re friends and former American Top Team teammates (Nunes left in 2022), so neither woman is walking into a mystery.
View post on X
The obvious plan is the losing plan
The game plan everybody sketches for Nunes is the one she’s always run: stand at range, load the right hand, look for the finish. The best case for it comes from Larissa Pacheco, the only fighter to beat Harrison, who told MMA Fighting that Nunes finishes her “very easily” and that “She has more weapons to win this fight than Kayla does.” Pacheco has earned the right to that opinion, and 13 knockouts are a real argument.
Here’s my problem with it. Every committed power shot is a weight shift, and a judoka spends her entire career learning to turn somebody else’s commitment into a throw. Nunes doesn’t get to decide whether this fight visits the clinch. She only gets to decide how often she offers it, and a missed hook with her hips squared up offers it on a plate. Once Harrison is attached, the chain starts. A stuffed trip becomes a body lock, the body lock becomes a mat return, and the mat return puts Nunes on her back with 3:40 left in the round and a very heavy person on her chest.
Three years off also costs a striker something specific. Timing on the counter is the first thing to rust, at least in my read of how layoffs tend to go, and Nunes’ best knockouts came from exactly that timing. Headhunting on rusty timing against an elite thrower is how you donate takedowns.
View post on X
Fight from the bottom like you mean it
What Nunes should do is stop treating her back as a crisis. When a striker gets taken down by a top-heavy grappler, the instinct is to wall-walk immediately, and that’s precisely the window chain wrestlers live in. You turn to stand, the next attempt is already coming, and the fighter on bottom keeps giving up position to chase her feet. Harrison wants that cycle repeating for 15 or 25 minutes.
Break it with the legs. When Harrison postures up to throw or steps a knee through to pass, that’s the moment to enter an ashi garami and go hunting: inside heel hook, straight ankle, whatever she can grab. I don’t care much whether it finishes. A leg entanglement forces Harrison to use her hips to defend instead of using them to pin, and every scramble out of a leg attack is a chance for Nunes to come up on top or stand with real separation instead of with a judoka hanging off her back. I’d also love to know how often Harrison has had to defend leg locks from somebody with Nunes’ strength in the hips, because my guess is not often, and you test that on the biggest night of the year.
There’s a scoring reason too, and it exasperates me. Judges tend to reward the fighter on top for control time even when the bottom fighter is working, but they do respond to visible submission threats. Attack from guard and the round looks contested. Lie flat and wait for the stand-up and you’re flirting with a 10-8 from judges who already hand those out like hotel mints. I’d rather Nunes not leave her title hopes to three people who score control like a rent payment.
Skeptics will say a striker with 13 knockouts shouldn’t reinvent herself at 38. Fair. But this isn’t reinventing anything. It’s using the half of her game she rarely needed against women she could just hit, against the one opponent where it might be the whole difference.
View post on X
Nunes said she’s here “as a double champion,” and she plans to keep fighting “until my body tells me.” If she wants that body to get a vote on Saturday, she needs to be willing to get it tangled up in Harrison’s legs.
My pick: Harrison by decision, because asking a knockout artist to fall in love with her guard in her first fight back is a big ask. If Nunes is hunting heels by Round 2, tear up my pick.
